Boxpressd Cigar App
  • Feed
  • Virtual Humidor
  • Journal
  • Cigar Discovery
  • Shop
  • Today's Deals
  • Local Pickup
  • Shop All
  • Nearby
  • Lounges & Shops
  • Upcoming Events
  • Social
  • Nubs
  • Saved Lists
  • Friends
  • Virtual Lounge
  • Groups
  • Help & Support
  • Contact
  • Cigar 101
  • Get Help
  • Request Feature

E.P. Carrillo
Sumatra

Average User Rating
83
AppearanceDrawBurnFlavor
Average Rating Based On 6 Ratings
James Patterson
James Patterson
Smoked Jul 2, 2025
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra
836
85
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Updated review, 11 months of rest. Flavor notes are of smooth chocolate with a little coffee, but there is also something grassy or hay like about it as well. The draw was overly airy this time, but the burn managed to stay even. Decent cigar but hasn't been consistent.
BL Luxuries
Bought at BL Luxuries
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Sprite Lemon-Lime Soda
Paired with Sprite Lemon-Lime Soda
Like
Comment
Share
James Patterson
James Patterson
Smoked May 17, 2025
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra
836
85
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Continued review. Well blended flavor notes of smooth chocolate with a little coffee, but there is also something grassy or hay like about it as well. The draw was slightly better this time than previously, however the burn did need if you touch ups this time around.
BL Luxuries
Bought at BL Luxuries
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Coca Cola Soda
Paired with Coca Cola Soda
Like
Comment
Share
James Patterson
James Patterson
Smoked Mar 23, 2025
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra
836
85
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
This cigar was smoother than I expected it to be. Flavor notes bring a profile of smooth chocolate with a little coffee, but there is also something grassy or hay like about it as well. The cigar burned faster than expected but it stayed evenly burned.
BL Luxuries
Bought at BL Luxuries
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Tampico Citrus Fruit Punch
Paired with Tampico Citrus Fruit Punch
Like
Comment
Share
Andy Adamek
Andy Adamek
Smoked Jul 3, 2024
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra
836
80
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Let me start by saying that out of the wrapper, this cigar looks and smells excellent. The cold draw is splendid with some sweet hay, chocolate and creamy yet strong espresso. I used a v-cutter. Upon lighting, I get the scent of bakers chocolate, coffee, and corn flakes. The first puff yields medium roast coffee, semi sweet cocoa powder. The first half inch of burn begins to canoe slightly, not my fault, I lit it perfectly. I ash at an inch, the draw has become subdued, time to stab it with the ol' draw doctor. The conoeing fixes itself after a while. The char line straightens put. The draw and smoke production improves dramatically after a little intercourse. The retro stays mostly the same but develops a medium brown sugar characteristic that I don't get very often. It compliments 5he subtle spicy notes well. I'm reminded of candied black pepper baken sans the maple syrup. The canoeing is back, more dramatically this time, what a shame. Gave er' a Lil touch up from the triple flame. I'm having a horrible day at work, today is my weekly closing shift, my counterpart handed me a steaming pile of shit this afternoon. Luckily, time stands still while I savor this cigar. For a medium bodied cigar, the retro is pretty mild, far creamier than I'd have expected. Anyone remember corn pops? Not the bad dude that Biden used to talk about, the breakfast cereal. I'm getting an ever so slight flavor that reminds me of that brand. I think I'm one of the few that enjoyed it fondly as a youngster. This cigar would pair excellently with a nice rioja or golden Jamaican rum. Speaking of Jamaica, they're really getting hammered by beryl, thoughts and prayers. I'm nearing the 2/3 mark and though it hasn't evolved much throughout the smoke, I've enjoyed it. Similar to a casa fuente at 1/3 the price. Pretty good cigar for $8 if you ask me. The final 3rd of the cigar gains an unwelcomed harshness but lacks the typical final 3rd ammonia of most newly released blends.
Black Pepper
Blonde Roast
Cereal / Grain
Espresso
Hay
Molasses
Must
Raisin
Lone Star Tobacco
Smoked at Lone Star Tobacco
Coke Zero
Paired with Coke Zero
Like
Comment
Share
Ryan Jackson
Ryan Jackson
Smoked Jul 16, 2025
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra
836
85
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Big Chief Cigar Company
Bought at Big Chief Cigar Company
Balvenie Doublewood 12y
Paired with Balvenie Doublewood 12y
Like
Comment
Share
Ryan Jackson
Ryan Jackson
Smoked Jul 2, 2025
E.P. Carrillo Sumatra
836
80
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Finck Cigars Stone Oak
Bought at Finck Cigars Stone Oak
Iced Coffee
Paired with Iced Coffee
Like
Comment
Share

Origin: Dominican Republic

Strength: Medium

Wrapper

  • Unknown

Binder

  • Unknown

Filler

  • Unknown
Top Flavor Notes
Black Pepper
Blonde Roast
Cereal / Grain
Espresso
Hay
Molasses
Must
Raisin

E.P. Carrillo Sumatra Vitolas

Gordo (6"x60)
Gordo (6"x60)
Robusto (5"x50)
Robusto (5"x50)
Toro (6"x52)
Toro (6"x52)

Where To Buy E.P. Carrillo Sumatra

No product details available
New Nubs PostCreate Smoke SessionAdd to HumidorReview Shop / LoungeRate ProductAdd / Invite Friends