Boxpressd Cigar App
  • Feed
  • Virtual Humidor
  • Journal
  • Cigar Discovery
  • Shop
  • Today's Deals
  • Local Pickup
  • Shop All
  • Nearby
  • Lounges & Shops
  • Upcoming Events
  • Social
  • Nubs
  • Saved Lists
  • Friends
  • Virtual Lounge
  • Groups
  • Help & Support
  • Contact
  • Cigar 101
  • Get Help
  • Request Feature

My Father
The Judge

Average User Rating
87
AppearanceDrawBurnFlavor
Average Rating Based On 98 Ratings
Michael Ratliff
Michael Ratliff
Smoked Jun 3, 2025
My Father The Judge
8798
90
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Excellent flavor, great draw. One of my favorites this year.
Official Hazy IPA
Paired with Official Hazy IPA
Like
Comment
Share
Julio Santana
Julio Santana
Smoked Feb 14, 2025
My Father The Judge
8798
80
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Great smoke! I see why it’s CA’s number 1
Like
Comment
Share
Chris Pac
Chris Pac
Smoked Aug 11, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
80
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Rate it a 3.5.
Like
Comment
Share
Ryan Permaul
Ryan Permaul
Smoked Jul 13, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
75
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Great people, great cigar
Mane Street Cigars & Lounge
Smoked at Mane Street Cigars & Lounge
Like
Comment
Share
Rod Yarrow
Rod Yarrow
Smoked Jul 1, 2024 for 1 hr 27 mins
My Father The Judge
8798
80
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Front deck, sunny/hot (26°C) with some wind.
JR Cigars
Bought at JR Cigars
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Wild Turkey 101 Proof Whisky United States
Paired with Wild Turkey 101 Proof Whisky United States
Like
Comment
Share
Rod Yarrow
Rod Yarrow
Smoked Jun 13, 2024 for 1 hr 05 mins
My Father The Judge
8798
June 14, 2024 at 15:00. Watching US Open at Pinehurst Round 1. Wonderful construction. Easy draw, even burn. Thick, heavy smoke, strong, slightly bitter taste. Could be the drink pairing.
Chocolate
Coffee Beans
JR Cigars
Bought at JR Cigars
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Jose Cuervo Authentic Lime Margarita
Paired with Jose Cuervo Authentic Lime Margarita
Like
Comment
Share
Rod Yarrow
Rod Yarrow
Smoked May 2, 2024 for 1 hr 31 mins
My Father The Judge
8798
97
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Cigar unlit smells of cocoa. Cap cuts clean. Burns evenly and at a nice pace. Draw is full and uninhibited. Full bodied smoke.
JR Cigars
Bought at JR Cigars
Radler
Paired with Radler
Like
Comment
Share
Adam Nelson
Adam Nelson
Smoked Mar 19, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
82
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Very good cigar.
Iowa Cigar Company
Bought at Iowa Cigar Company
Like
Comment
Share
John Engel
John Engel
Smoked Mar 16, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
100
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Delicious, good draw and a perfect burn line the whole way down. What more can I ask for on a Friday night
Neptune Cigar SuperStore
Bought at Neptune Cigar SuperStore
Vanilla Stout
Paired with Vanilla Stout
Like
Comment
Share
Henry Head
Henry Head
Smoked Feb 17, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
90
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Excellent cigar! Starts out with a blast of pepper then quickly chocolate, wood, earth and leather. A touch of sweetness and nuttiness in the background. Lots of complexity as the 2nd and 3rd thirds burn, very smooth flavor transitions with honey and licorice showing up in the final 3rd.
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Water
Paired with Water
Like
Comment
Share
Joshua E
Joshua E
Smoked Feb 12, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
82
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
On first light there were notes of chocolate and pepper. The cigar had uneven burn (may have been the wind). I had to do multiple touch ups.
Dr. Pepper
Paired with Dr. Pepper
Like
Comment
Share
Henry Head
Henry Head
Smoked Feb 8, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
90
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Excellent smoke, full strength but still smooth. Lots of complexity to flavor/ tastes
C&S Cigar Lounge
Smoked at C&S Cigar Lounge
Like
Comment
Share
Connoisseur’s Cut
Connoisseur’s Cut
Smoked Feb 4, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
Connoisseur’s take: this is my second time smoking this cigar and it’s even better than I remember. With flavors of dark coffee, chocolate, nuts, and graham cracker, this is an amazing dessert cigar. I advise everyone to smoke this cigar!
Like
Comment
Share
Kyle King
Kyle King
Smoked Jan 2, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
82
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
The Judge looks and feels like what a cigar should be. Construction was solid. Smoke was good and it burned fairly even once it got started. Flavor is where this fell short as I did not get much complexity like others mention but the spice and nutty tastes that I did get were clean.
Like
Comment
Share
Joshua Wulf
Joshua Wulf
Smoked Jan 1, 2024 for 1 hr 22 mins
My Father The Judge
8798
97
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Great Smoke! Smooth light retrohale. Good flavor of Cinnamon and chocolate. Enjoyable smoke.
Black Pepper
Chocolate
Cinnamon
Espresso
Leather
Cigars Daily
Bought at Cigars Daily
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Like
Comment
Share
Henry Head
Henry Head
Smoked Dec 31, 2023
My Father The Judge
8798
87
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
An amazing smoke. The complexity and flavors were off the charts. Coffee, chocolate, malt, fruitiness, earth, leather, wood and spice. Multiple transitions and changes throughout the smoke.
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Like
Comment
Share
Billy Whitehouse
Billy Whitehouse
Smoked Jun 18, 2023
My Father The Judge
8798
87
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Second time smoking. Very enjoyable
Like
Comment
Share
Sean P
Sean P
Smoked May 2, 2023
My Father The Judge
8798
97
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Great stick. Perfect burn. Very strong and great flavors of cinnamon and cedar. Last third is very strong!
Like
Comment
Share
Michael Purcell
Michael Purcell
Smoked Feb 25, 2023
My Father The Judge
8798
90
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
A few imperfections to include a tear in the wrapper while the band was removed. Still a great cigar!
Caramel
Dark Roast
Earth
Leather
Cigars International Superstore Fort Worth
Bought at Cigars International Superstore Fort Worth
Like
Comment
Share
Cam L
Cam L
Smoked Jul 10, 2022
My Father The Judge
8798
100
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Always my favorite. You can never go wrong with this stick. V cut and lit with a torch.
Federal Cigar
Bought at Federal Cigar
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Like
Comment
Share
Zack Steffel
Zack Steffel
Smoked May 20, 2022
My Father The Judge
8798
82
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Had to touch it up a couple times, but mostly because I was in and out of the house, setting the cigar down frequently. Started out at 75° and dropped down to low 60s. It's chilly outside but the cigar is nice and dark and keeping me warm. Lots of chocolatey flavor with earth and a saltiness.
Chocolate
Dark Roast
Earth
Raisin
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Like
Comment
Share
K.P. Narcisse
K.P. Narcisse
Smoked Oct 21, 2021 for 1 hr 50 mins
My Father The Judge
8798
92
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
This is an excellent cigar. I enjoyed this stick from the beginning to the end. Nice medium to full body cigar that went well with Uncle Nearest. A great relaxation from a long day. One of my favorites from my start of enjoying the leaf.💨💨
Black Pepper
Dark Roast
Leather
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Uncle Nearest 1856 Tennessee Whiskey Tennessee United States
Paired with Uncle Nearest 1856 Tennessee Whiskey Tennessee United States
Like
Comment
Share
Ty Williams
Ty Williams
Smoked Aug 13, 2018
My Father The Judge
8798
97
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Hands down still my favorite
Nick's Cigar World
Bought at Nick's Cigar World
Breckenridge Bourbon Whiskey Aged at Least 2 Years In Charred Oak Barrels
Paired with Breckenridge Bourbon Whiskey Aged at Least 2 Years In Charred Oak Barrels
Like
Comment
Share
Ty Williams
Ty Williams
Smoked Jun 23, 2018
My Father The Judge
8798
100
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
One of my new favorites
Blantons Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Paired with Blantons Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Like
Comment
Share
Roberto Velasquez
Roberto Velasquez
Smoked May 1, 2025
My Father The Judge
8798
70
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Like
Comment
Share
John Engel
John Engel
Smoked Apr 27, 2025
My Father The Judge
8798
97
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Neptune Cigar SuperStore
Bought at Neptune Cigar SuperStore
Like
Comment
Share
Jonathan Ellis
Jonathan Ellis
Smoked Nov 14, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
Like
Comment
Share
Sovida Tran
Sovida Tran
Smoked Nov 9, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
90
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Capital Cigar Lounge
Smoked at Capital Cigar Lounge
Old Fashioned
Paired with Old Fashioned
Like
Comment
Share
John Engel
John Engel
Smoked Nov 3, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
92
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Holt's Cigar Company
Bought at Holt's Cigar Company
Like
Comment
Share
CF Dior
CF Dior
Smoked Oct 11, 2024
My Father The Judge
8798
90
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Like
Comment
Share

Origin: Nicaragua

Strength: Medium-Full

Wrapper

  • Unknown

Binder

  • Unknown

Filler

  • Unknown
Top Flavor Notes
Black Pepper
Caramel
Cereal / Grain
Cinnamon
Clove
Coffee Beans
Dark Roast
Earth
Espresso
Grass
Leather
Molasses
Peanut
Plum
Raisin
Cedar / Oak

My Father The Judge Vitolas

5.5"x50
5.5"x50
Box-Pressed (Toro Box Press - 6.0"x56)
Box-Pressed (Toro Box Press - 6.0"x56)
Corona Gorda ( 5.12"x46 )
Corona Gorda ( 5.12"x46 )
Corona Gorda (5.12"x46)
Corona Gorda (5.12"x46)
Corona Gorda (5.6"x46)
Corona Gorda (5.6"x46)
Corona Gorda (5.6"x46)
Corona Gorda (5.6"x46)
Gordo Box-Pressed (5.0"x60)
Gordo Box-Pressed (5.0"x60)
Gran Robusto ( 5"x60 )
Gran Robusto ( 5"x60 )
Gran Robusto (5.0"x60)
Gran Robusto (5.0"x60)
Robusto Gordo (5.0"x60)
Robusto Gordo (5.0"x60)
Robusto Gordo (5.0"x60)
Robusto Gordo (5.0"x60)
Toro ( 6"x56 )
Toro ( 6"x56 )
Toro (6.0"x52)
Toro (6.0"x52)
Toro (6.0"x52)
Toro (6.0"x52)
Toro (6.0"x56)
Toro (6.0"x56)
Toro (6.0"x56)
Toro (6.0"x56)
Toro Fino (Box-Pressed) ( 6"x52 )
Toro Fino (Box-Pressed) ( 6"x52 )
Toro Fino (Box-Pressed) (6.0"x52)
Toro Fino (Box-Pressed) (6.0"x52)
Toro Fino (Toro - 6"x52)
Toro Fino (Toro - 6"x52)
Tubo (Corona gorda - 5.6"x46)
Tubo (Corona gorda - 5.6"x46)
Tubo (Robusto - 5"x60)
Tubo (Robusto - 5"x60)
New Nubs PostCreate Smoke SessionAdd to HumidorReview Shop / LoungeRate ProductAdd / Invite Friends

Where To Buy My Father The Judge

  • My Father The Judge (Box of 23)
    My Father The Judge Corona Gorda (5.12"x46) - Box of 23

    0 ratings
    Sold by JR Cigars

  • My Father The Judge (Box of 23)
    My Father The Judge Gran Robusto (5.0"x60) - Box of 23

    0 ratings
    Sold by JR Cigars

  • My Father The Judge (Box of 23)
    My Father The Judge Toro (6.0"x56) - Box of 23

    0 ratings
    Sold by JR Cigars

  • My Father The Judge (Box of 23)
    My Father The Judge Corona Gorda (5.12"x46) - Box of 23

    0 ratings
    Sold by Casa de Montecristo Online

  • My Father The Judge (Box of 23)
    My Father The Judge Corona Gorda (5.6"x46) - Box of 23

    0 ratings
    Sold by Cigar Page

  • My Father The Judge (Pack of 5)
    My Father The Judge Corona Gorda (5.6"x46) - Pack of 5

    0 ratings
    Sold by Cigar Page

  • My Father The Judge (Box of 23)
    My Father The Judge - Box of 23

    0 ratings
    Sold by Neptune Cigar

  • My Father The Judge (Single)
    My Father The Judge - Single

    0 ratings
    Sold by Neptune Cigar

  • My Father The Judge (Single)
    My Father The Judge - Single

    0 ratings
    Sold by Neptune Cigar